Senators Press CFTC to Drop Geofencing Order
Nine Democratic senators led by Adam Schiff have told the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to withdraw its order banning prediction markets from geofencing by state, or freeze it until the courts are done. The letter went to CFTC Chairman Michael Selig on Monday, November 16, eleven days after the agency told exchanges to stop blocking traders by state.
The senators also want the CFTC to preserve every record and message on the subject going back to January 1, 2025, and to confirm in writing by November 23 that it is doing so. Democrats take control of Congress in January, which gives a records request like that real weight.
Who Signed and Why
Schiff, a California Democrat on the Senate Agriculture Committee, was joined by every senator from the four states where, according to the letter, courts have already reined in prediction markets. That’s Alex Padilla of California, Catherine Cortez Masto and Jacky Rosen of Nevada, Maria Cantwell and Patty Murray of Washington, and Elissa Slotkin and Gary Peters of Michigan. Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota, the committee’s ranking member, signed too.
The target is the CFTC’s November 5 interpretation of its impartial access rule, Regulation 38.151(b). It gave exchanges 30 days to drop domestic geographic restrictions or explain to the agency’s Division of Market Oversight why they cannot. Selig said at the time that “derivatives markets must operate on a uniform basis at a national scale” and that geographic restrictions are inconsistent with the Commodity Exchange Act.
The Court Orders in the Way
The senators’ letter argues that courts have ordered platforms to stop offering some contracts in Michigan, Nevada and Washington and on the land of two California tribes, and in several cases required geofencing. It says the Sixth and Ninth Circuits have ruled that states can apply their gaming laws to prediction markets.
“The Commission now appears to be encouraging prediction markets to offer prohibited contracts in contempt of these court orders during active litigation,” the senators wrote.
The Timing Question
The sharpest line in the letter is about timing. The senators said they were “particularly troubled” that the interpretation landed “just hours after” a federal court in Northern California ordered Kalshi to geofence around tribal land in Blue Lake Rancheria v. Kalshi, the case behind the tribal land injunction.
That, they wrote, “raises concerns that the Commission may be coordinating with platforms currently engaged in litigation.” The letter does not cite evidence of coordination. It’s an allegation, and the records request looks built to test it.
What the Senators Want Now
The senators’ release sets out the core demand in one line. “The Commission must withdraw the interpretation or freeze all efforts to implement until litigation is resolved.”
At a minimum, they want the CFTC to state that three kinds of geographic limits do not break the rule. Those are limits imposed by a court order, limits adopted to comply with the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act or tribal-state compacts, and limits an exchange chooses on its own.
The CFTC Is Also Probing Kalshi and Polymarket
The letter landed on the same day Politico reported that the CFTC is running separate probes into Kalshi and Polymarket, which it called “the two dominant platforms.” Selig has championed the industry since taking over the agency last December, and Politico read the investigations as a sign that he is stepping up his oversight.
The Kalshi probe looks at whether it properly told the agency about proposed contracts. Kalshi confirmed the CFTC investigation to CNBC, and its head of communications, Elisabeth Diana, called it “a procedural error involving the submission of a handful of contracts, many of which weren’t live.”
Polymarket’s 2022 Deal
The Polymarket review goes back further. According to CNBC, the CFTC is checking whether Polymarket broke its 2022 settlement, under which it shut US users out of its platform and paid a $1.4 million civil penalty. The agency is also looking at the controls Polymarket uses to detect where customers are, and at its advertising in the US.
Pressure From Both Ends
The squeeze on Kalshi kept going after the letter. On Tuesday, November 17, Kalshi confirmed to CNBC that it had paused several mention markets tied to what President Donald Trump will say, at the CFTC’s request. CFTC spokesperson Brooke Nethercott said the agency stayed those contracts because “they may be susceptible to manipulation.”
So the CFTC is fighting the states in court on behalf of prediction markets while it investigates the two biggest platforms itself. The geofencing order is where those two roles collide, and it’s the part of the fight over prediction market law that the senators want frozen. The 30-day window from November 5 runs out in early December, and the senators asked for an answer by November 23.