Open menu
California flag and a casino on tribal land among oak-covered hills at night behind a land map with a boundary drawn in red, a gavel, a sealed court order, a football and a phone showing a location-blocked prediction market app
Nick Hall
Nick Hall
Senior Editor

Updated 09 / 11 / 2026

Judge Bars Kalshi Sports Contracts on Tribal Land

Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley of the US District Court for the Northern District of California has barred Kalshi from offering sports contracts on the Indian lands of the tribes suing it in California. The one-page order, dated Wednesday, November 4, grants the tribes a preliminary injunction in Blue Lake Rancheria v. Kalshi, case No. 3:25-cv-06162.

It isn’t a statewide ban. The order names Kalshi Inc. and KalshiEX and covers only the plaintiff tribes’ lands, but on those lands it reaches any sports contract. It lists 14 sports by name, from baseball and pickleball to chess, esports and Ultimate Fighting Championship events, and says the ban is “not limited to” them.

Maps First, Then a Compliance Report

The order sets two dates. The tribes must hand Kalshi maps of their Indian lands by November 13, and Kalshi must tell the court within 21 days what it has done to comply, which puts its status report due on November 25.

The suit was brought by Blue Lake Rancheria and Chicken Ranch Rancheria of Me-Wuk Indians. On October 21, Corley let a third tribe, Buena Vista Rancheria of Me-Wuk Indians, join as a plaintiff, after Kalshi and Robinhood dropped their opposition.

The Ninth Circuit Did the Heavy Lifting

Corley turned the tribes down the first time, in November 2025. On September 16, a Ninth Circuit panel reversed her in part, 3-0, in the tribes’ appeal win. Judge M. Margaret McKeown wrote that Kalshi’s sports contracts are likely class III gaming under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act, or IGRA, the federal law that governs gambling on Indian lands. Class III is the casino-style category, and federal courts have said it includes sports betting.

The panel also decided where the bet happens. A contract is “located on Indian lands” when the user enters it from tribal territory, wherever Kalshi’s exchange sits. And it rejected Kalshi’s main defense, that the CFTC’s “exclusive” jurisdiction over derivatives shuts out IGRA. “The CEA may grant the Commission sole sway over its own field, but it neither negates IGRA nor bars federal courts from hearing a claim under it,” McKeown wrote. The panel sent the case back for Corley to weigh the remaining injunction factors, and this order is the result.

Why These Tribes Had a Case

The two tribes run their gaming under secretarial procedures, rules the Interior Department wrote for them in 2024 after compact talks with California stalled. Those rules treat class III gaming as lawful only when the tribe authorizes it. Nobody authorized Kalshi, and California doesn’t allow sports betting at all, unlike the many states where sports betting is legal.

Kalshi Said It Had Already Geofenced

Kalshi argued the injunction wasn’t needed. In an October 14 joint status report, it told the court that after the Ninth Circuit ruling it had worked with GeoComply to geofence the tribes’ lands, so people there “should not be able to trade sports event contracts” on its app or website. It called the injunction motion moot.

The tribes said a member of the Blue Lake Rancheria Gaming Commission then placed a “bet” on the Kalshi app while on the reservation. Kalshi said its measures were in place by September 23. The tribes first said the trade happened on September 25, then put it on October 2, and Kalshi said it was looking into it with GeoComply. The tribes asked for an order they could enforce, including by moving to hold Kalshi in contempt if the geofence failed. On November 4 they got one.

Robinhood Is Not Named

The injunction binds Kalshi Inc. and KalshiEX only. Robinhood Markets and Robinhood Derivatives, a futures commission merchant that routes customer orders to Kalshi, are also defendants. The tribes told the court in October they would add IGRA claims against Robinhood, which said it expects to oppose them, and Corley’s October 21 order cleared the tribes to amend.

A Geofence the CFTC Wants Gone

The timing is awkward for Kalshi. A day after the order, on November 5, the CFTC issued an interpretation of its impartial access rule. It says federal law “generally” does not let an exchange limit access based on where an otherwise eligible trader is located in the United States. Exchanges must drop domestic geographic restrictions within 30 days, which runs to December 5, or explain to the agency’s Division of Market Oversight why they can’t.

CFTC Chairman Michael S. Selig said in the release, “Geographic access restrictions are inconsistent with those purposes and the Act’s impartial access requirements.” So Kalshi now faces a federal regulator telling it to stop geofencing and a federal court ordering it to geofence. A court order could be the kind of explanation that route allows for. The state fights, including Nevada’s, one of Kalshi’s appeals court losses, turn on whether federal law preempts state gambling law, while this one turns on IGRA.

What Kalshi and the Tribes Have Said

After the Ninth Circuit ruling, Kalshi spokesperson Elisabeth Diana told Reuters the company may appeal. “This ruling is hard to square with other federal laws, which leave regulation of on-exchange derivatives trades exclusively to the [Commodity Futures Trading Commission],” she said. The tribes’ lawyer, Les Marston, said Kalshi “could have easily spent a few million dollars to geofence the tribes’ operations.”

A bipartisan group of 27 states and Washington, D.C. backed the tribes on appeal. Kalshi advertised that “Sports Betting [Is] Legal in all 50 States on Kalshi.” On these reservations a federal judge has now ordered the opposite, and the maps that draw the line are due on November 13.

Written by

Nick Hall

Senior Editor

Nick's passion for fast paced action has seen him test Bugattis for professional car reviews for the world's biggest car magazine, to covering the high octane world of online casinos, gambling regulation and emerging Web3 trends.

View all posts by Nick Hall
Nick Hall
Senior Editor
288+
Articles written

Nick's passion for fast paced action has seen him test Bugattis for professional car reviews for the world's biggest car magazine, to covering the high octane world of online casinos, gambling regulation and emerging Web3 trends.

Related News