AGA Says Voters See Prediction Markets as Gambling
A new survey from the American Gaming Association found that 82% of respondents think prediction markets should be regulated as gambling products, not financial products. The AGA, the casino industry’s national trade group, published it on Monday, November 16, as federal regulators and state attorneys general fight in court over who gets to police sports event contracts, the latest chapter in the state fights over prediction markets.
The AGA release calls the result bipartisan, and the split backs that up. Agreement ran at 84% of Democrats, 82% of Republicans and 80% of independents.
What the Survey Actually Asked
Qualtrics ran the online survey from September 2 to 18 among 2,268 registered voters aged 21 and older, with a margin of error of plus or minus 2 points. The release describes them as “Americans”, but the sample is voters, so treat it that way.
The headline question asked whether prediction markets “should be regulated as gambling products like sports bets, or financial products like swaps or futures contracts?” A separate 75% agreed that sports betting on a prediction market is fundamentally the same product as betting at a sportsbook.
The most striking number is about confusion. Half of respondents, 50%, wrongly believe prediction markets are state-licensed sportsbooks. That matters because they aren’t. Kalshi and its rivals operate under the federal Commodity Futures Trading Commission, which is why they’re available in all 50 states, including those that never legalized sports betting.
What Voters Expect From the Platforms
Most respondents want the same guardrails that licensed sportsbooks carry. 74% said the platforms should verify that every user is at least 21, and the same share wanted Responsible Gambling messages and a helpline in their ads. 71% said they should be licensed by the state gaming regulator, and 70% said they should honor state self-exclusion lists.
On risk, respondents rated a prediction-market bet at 7.1 out of 10, level with buying cryptocurrency and above a casino bet at 7.0 or a sports bet at 6.9. A 30-year mortgage scored 5.2. The AGA also says prediction-market users rated their own bets as no riskier than a mortgage, but that group was just 140 people.
A Poll With a Side in the Fight
The AGA is not a neutral pollster. Its members include MGM Resorts, PENN Entertainment, Las Vegas Sands and tribal operators such as the Seminole Tribe of Florida, companies whose sports and casino business runs on state and tribal licenses. DraftKings and FanDuel aren’t on that list anymore. Both quit the AGA in November 2025, before moving into prediction markets themselves, as Front Office Sports reported at the time.
AGA President and CEO Bill Miller didn’t soften the pitch. “Insidiously misrepresenting sports betting as an investment to 18-year-olds, and telling them it can pay their rent or college tuition, is a grotesque business practice,” he said, adding that Americans “and 47 attorneys general agree” that the platforms should face the same rules as state-licensed books.
Kalshi Ran Its Own Numbers
The other side has polls too. Kalshi commissioned Axis Research to survey 1,219 voters in September 2025, and that poll found 79% wanted “Federal Government Regulators” overseeing these markets rather than “State Gaming Commissions”, while 89% said all Americans should have access to them. Kalshi published the results on its own news site.
Both polls were paid for by a side with money riding on the answer, and the question wording does a lot of the work. A March 2026 Ipsos poll of 2,363 adults for the American Institute for Boys and Men found 61% saw event contracts as closer to gambling and just 8% as closer to investing. Only 21% of that sample said they were familiar with prediction markets at all.
The Week the Poll Landed
The survey landed in a busy week. The CFTC sued Arkansas on November 12 and Louisiana on November 13, and its Louisiana release called Louisiana the 12th state the agency has sued over its claimed jurisdiction. Chairman Michael Selig called Louisiana’s state court case “naked lawfare and a cynical political stunt.” Those suits against Arkansas and Louisiana are the clearest sign yet that Washington won’t leave this to the states.
On November 5, the agency also told exchanges to drop domestic geographic restrictions within 30 days, the geofencing order that would end state-by-state blocking on federally regulated exchanges. A survey saying voters want state licensing lands squarely against that order.
For anyone placing bets, the gap between the legal sportsbook map and the prediction-market map is the real point. In most states, a licensed book has to check that you’re 21, honor self-exclusion and carry a helpline, and half of the voters surveyed believe prediction markets are already state-licensed sportsbooks.