Open menu
The US Supreme Court building at dusk with a neon 1-3 sign above three stacked court opinions, a gavel and a phone showing a yes or no market
Nick Hall
Nick Hall
Senior Editor

Updated 19 / 11 / 2026

Kalshi’s Court Losses Point to the Supreme Court

Key Takeaways

  • The Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 for Maryland on November 18, but its three judges gave three different answers on whether Kalshi’s sports contracts are swaps and whether federal law shuts out state gambling law.
  • Four federal appeals courts have now ruled at the preliminary injunction stage, and only the Third Circuit has backed Kalshi, while the Sixth, Ninth and Fourth Circuits have let states enforce their gambling laws.
  • New Jersey’s Supreme Court petition, No. 26-299, is backed by Ohio, 38 other states and DC, the NFL and 145 tribes, and Kalshi’s response is now due on December 7.

The Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 against Kalshi on November 18, clearing Maryland to enforce its sports betting laws against the prediction market. The three judges on the panel then wrote three separate opinions, and no two of them agree on why. That makes four federal appeals courts to rule on Kalshi’s sports contracts, and only one, the Third Circuit, has sided with the company, on top of the appeals court setbacks Kalshi took earlier in November.

Put the scorecard next to the reasoning and the picture is clear. The states are winning the votes, but the courts can’t settle the law between them, and only the US Supreme Court can do that. New Jersey has already asked it to. Meanwhile Kalshi is reportedly in talks to raise money at a $65 billion valuation, a price built on a legal theory that has now lost in three circuits out of four.

One Appeal, Three Opinions

The court’s own ruling is one line long. “The judgment of the district court is AFFIRMED,” the per curiam opinion says, which leaves in place a District of Maryland order that refused to block the state. Everything else sits in the separate opinions.

Judge Roger Gregory skipped the biggest question in the case. “I do not decide whether Kalshi’s sports event contracts are ‘swaps’ within the meaning of the CEA,” he wrote, referring to the Commodity Exchange Act. Even if they are, he said, the law doesn’t clearly displace Maryland’s power over gambling. Judge Stephanie Thacker went further. In her view the contracts “are not swaps within the meaning of the CEA” at all, and what Kalshi offers is “gambling, plain and simple.”

A Dissent That Backs Kalshi

Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin dissented. She found the contracts are swaps, and “because Congress has granted ‘exclusive jurisdiction’ over such swaps to the CFTC,” she would have sent the case back in Kalshi’s favor.

Diagram of the three Fourth Circuit opinions in KalshiEX v. Martin, decided November 18, 2026: Judge Gregory did not decide whether the contracts are swaps and found federal law does not clearly displace Maryland, so he affirmed; Judge Thacker found the contracts are not swaps, so Maryland can regulate them and she affirmed; Judge Benjamin found they are swaps under the CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction and would have vacated and remanded. Result: affirmed 2-1 for Maryland with no shared reasoning
Two votes for Maryland, two different reasons.

Kalshi Reads the Split as a Win

Kalshi’s response made the most of the disagreement. “Judges can’t agree with each other on why we’re wrong,” a Kalshi spokesperson told CBS Baltimore. “This splintered decision, including three separate contradictory opinions, demonstrates there is no unified coherent legal argument against prediction markets.”

Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown saw the same ruling very differently. “Today’s ruling means Kalshi must meet the same consumer protection standards as every other sportsbook serving Maryland residents,” he said. Both statements are true in their own way. The reasoning is splintered, but the judgment is the part that decides what Maryland can do next.

The Scorecard Across Four Circuits

The fight started in 2025, when Kalshi sued states that sent it cease-and-desist letters. Maryland’s came on April 7, 2025, and Kalshi filed suit two weeks later. Since then the appeals courts have lined up like this.

The Third Circuit went first and went Kalshi’s way. On April 6, 2026 it upheld an injunction against New Jersey by 2-1, finding Kalshi had “a reasonable chance of success” on preemption. Judge Jane Roth dissented, warning that Kalshi’s reading of a swap could cover “a bet over the outcome of a friendly neighborhood ping pong match.”

Scorecard of the federal appeals courts that have ruled on Kalshi's sports event contracts: the Third Circuit, New Jersey, April 6, 2026, ruled 2-1 for Kalshi, finding the contracts are swaps under the CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction; the Ninth Circuit, Nevada, August 28, 2026, ruled for the state, finding the contracts are likely not swaps; the Sixth Circuit, Ohio and Tennessee, September 25, 2026, ruled for the states; the Fourth Circuit, Maryland, November 18, 2026, ruled 2-1 for the state with no shared reasoning; the Second Circuit, New York and Connecticut, November 3, 2026, denied Kalshi an injunction pending appeal. One win for Kalshi, three for the states
One appeals court for Kalshi, three against, and a fourth that refused to step in.

Three Rulings for the States

Everything since has gone the other way. The Ninth Circuit ruled for Nevada on August 28, finding the contracts “are likely not swaps under the CEA” and adding that “Kalshi has a gambling problem.” On September 25 the Sixth Circuit cleared Ohio and Tennessee to go after the company, and on November 3 the Second Circuit refused to stop New York and Connecticut while those appeals run, in a one-paragraph order.

None of These Is a Final Ruling

Every one of these decisions came at the preliminary injunction stage. The courts were asking whether Kalshi is likely to win, not handing down a final judgment. That still matters a great deal, because without an injunction the states don’t have to wait for the trials to finish before they enforce.

Why the Split in Reasoning Matters More

Judge Gregory said it plainly in his concurrence. Whether contracts like these count as swaps “has divided courts considering the question and presents difficult and technical questions of statutory interpretation.” Kalshi’s case really turns on two questions, and the courts keep answering different ones.

The first is whether a sports contract is a swap at all. Dodd-Frank, the 2010 law that put swaps under the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, covers deals tied to an event “associated with a potential financial, economic, or commercial consequence.” The Third Circuit and Judge Benjamin say a game result fits. The Ninth and Sixth Circuits and Judge Thacker say it doesn’t.

The second question is what happens if they are swaps. Judge Benjamin noted that even the Ninth Circuit’s reasoning “supports the position that if Kalshi’s event contracts are ‘swaps,’ they fall under the CFTC’s exclusive jurisdiction.” Judge Gregory is the outlier here. He found that even a swap doesn’t clearly push aside a state’s gambling law, which gives the states a second way to win.

The Case Already Waiting at the Supreme Court

The Supreme Court hasn’t agreed to hear anything yet, but it already has the vehicle. New Jersey filed its petition, No. 26-299, on September 2 against the Third Circuit’s ruling, and the NFL and dozens of states have urged the justices to take it.

The question presented is a single sentence. “Whether the 2010 Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act preempted States from regulating sports bets that occur within their jurisdictions if those bets are offered on markets registered with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission.” New Jersey’s petition says the litigation has “dragged at least 20 States into litigation” and that 95% of Kalshi’s revenue in 2025 came from sports-related betting.

The Supreme Court building in Washington at dusk with its columns lit from below, brass scales, a law book and an American flag in the foreground

Who Has Lined Up Against Kalshi

The amicus list on the Supreme Court docket is long. It includes a brief for Ohio, 38 other states and the District of Columbia, one for 145 Indian tribes and tribal organizations, and separate filings from the NFL, the American Gaming Association, former CFTC chairman Gary Gensler and former senator Christopher Dodd.

Kalshi, represented by former Solicitor General Paul Clement, has had its response deadline pushed back twice, from October 8 to November 9 and then to December 7. Once that brief is in, the justices can take up the petition at a conference. The Fourth Circuit decision gives them one more split ruling to read.

Timeline of New Jersey's Supreme Court petition No. 26-299 against Kalshi: Third Circuit ruling April 6, 2026; petition filed September 2 and docketed September 8; amicus briefs filed from September 22 to October 8, including Ohio with 38 other states and DC, the NFL, 145 tribes and the American Gaming Association; Kalshi's response deadline moved from October 8 to November 9 and then to December 7; the Fourth Circuit ruled November 18 while the petition was pending
The petition has been waiting since September 2.

The Federal Regulator Is on Kalshi’s Side

The states aren’t only fighting Kalshi. The CFTC is suing them. On November 13 it filed against Louisiana, which it called the 12th state it has sued “to defend its exclusive jurisdiction over derivatives markets,” and it has also filed amicus briefs in four federal courts of appeal and one state Supreme Court. That fight runs alongside its suits against Arkansas and Louisiana.

CFTC Chairman Michael Selig called Louisiana’s lawsuit “naked lawfare and a cynical political stunt.” The agency’s backing hasn’t moved the appeals courts much, though. Three of the four that have ruled on Kalshi’s sports contracts still left the states free to enforce.

A Baltimore rowhouse stoop at night with a phone on the step showing a generic yes or no football market and a folded official letter beside it

What the Valuation Is Betting On

Kalshi’s investors are looking past all of this. Bloomberg, as reported by Quartz, says the company is in talks at $65 billion, weeks after a round at $40 billion, and that its monthly trading volume grew from $40 billion in August to close to $100 billion in October. Sports made up the bulk of trading over the past year.

That’s the exposure. A Supreme Court win for the states would mean sports contracts answer to state gambling law in every state that wants to enforce it, the way licensed sportsbooks already do. A win for Kalshi would let one federal license stand in for dozens of state ones. Both are still possible, and the state-by-state fights will keep going until the justices pick one.

Four federal appeals courts have now looked at the same contracts. Only one has called them swaps beyond the reach of state law, and that’s the ruling New Jersey has asked the Supreme Court to reverse.

Written by

Nick Hall

Senior Editor

Nick's passion for fast paced action has seen him test Bugattis for professional car reviews for the world's biggest car magazine, to covering the high octane world of online casinos, gambling regulation and emerging Web3 trends.

View all posts by Nick Hall
Nick Hall
Senior Editor
301+
Articles written

Nick's passion for fast paced action has seen him test Bugattis for professional car reviews for the world's biggest car magazine, to covering the high octane world of online casinos, gambling regulation and emerging Web3 trends.

Related News